We are finally podcast! Finally here to deliver all the nerd goodness you could want. I’m joined by fellow anime and gaming gurus Song, Mog and Rees to discuss how we fell down the slippery slope of nerdiness, to talk recent news, revel in the 40 anime questions and more. Not all future podcasts will be as long as this one, hence we decided to separate episode 1 into two parts. Find the show notes below!
Side A: 0:00 – Introductions 07:50 – What we’ve been up to (including “House of the Sun”, “World of Horror”, “Spring 2019 anime” and more) 51:00 – This month in news (including “Star Wars: Jedi: Fallen Order”, “Sekiro difficulty”, “Borderlands 3” and more)
Side B: 0:00 – The 40 anime questions 1:31:35 – The Super Secret Stolen Segment 1:39:05 – Outro
The intro/ outro song is “Matters to Me” by “Poker Face” from “Dirty Pair: Project Eden”.
In this episode we answered a question on anime harems, but who had the best? Answer our poll so we can determine who has the best taste in the opposite sex. https://www.strawpoll.me/17950448
I was unfamiliar with the source material of “Rinshi!!” Ekoda-Chan”, a series of 4-koma or 4-panel gag manga which ran from 2005-2014, but what attracted me to the 2019 series was the unique production style. They gave twelve directors free reign (within reason) to each create a 3-minute short based on the source material, which included the art style, lead voice actress and music composers. As such this was an art series which, thought nothing revolutionary, was an interesting look into how different key figures in the industry interpret the same work in different ways. It’s also an educational insight into the medium of directing, with each episode also followed by a 22-minute interview with the director, lead voice actress and occasionally additional staff. I didn’t watch these segments in full though, it depended on the ratio of how much they talked about their vision for the episode versus how much was spent on irelevant stories like how the production team met.
The manga is the sole work of Yukari Takinami and ran in the “Monthly Afternoon” magazine for an adult audience. Being 25 when it began publishing, Yukari based the manga shorts off her own life as a single woman in Tokyo without a goal, drifting between relationships and jobs (usually hostess bars). Clearly it’s aimed at a very specific audience, relateable shorts for working women, despite most anime directors being middle-aged/elderly men. Titular character Ekoda seems to be framed as an out-there city woman who sits at home naked and battles against “moukin”, or “birds of prey”, women who use cuteness as a weapon to get ahead. There was a previous series of shorts in 2011 however it isn’t widely available. Though there are many other series consisting of different director’s works, it’s rare to see such a variety of takes on the same property.
Episode 1 – Directed by Daichi Akitaro
Previous Works: “Fruits Basket”, “Now and Then, Here and There”, “Sexy Commando Gaide”, “Nurse Angel Ririka SOS”, etc.
I remember the interview of this episode specifically as it starts with Akitaro saying how the shows he’s worked on similar to this didn’t do well and that he was tempted to turn down working on this because he doesn’t like having so little time to tell a story. Not the best way to start your series off perhaps. He has a lot of previous directoral roles but they vary a lot in quality, many just being average with somewhat heavy handed plotlines. He seems to have a “tell rather than show” style.
This is a very “by-the-books” adaption leading to just a generally fine episode. It’s made up of four short segments that give a good showcase of the character and the tone, seperated by short clips of her dancing naked to lively music. The first sketch covers the difficulty of seeming mature for her age, the second is about societal independence meaning less chance to rely on others, the third about people being physically draining and the last about feeling like she’s gone nowhere in life. None of the jokes hit particuarly well nor is the art style used in an interesting way, instead just looking cheaply made. The rhythm of the show works well however, you can tell he wanted to get through as much content as possible but in the end this was more detrimental.
Episode 2 – Directed by Sugii Gisaburou
Previous Works: “Dororo” 1969, “Night on the Galactic Railroad”, “Street Fighter II Movie”, “Arashi no Yoru ni”, “Glass Mask”, etc.
This is a far more interesting episode than the first (and not just because I’m a huge fan of Gisaburou’s “Night on the Galactic Railroad”). Gisaburou is considered a classic director, with his use of dramatic and meaningful set pieces. This episode consists of Ekoda sat plucking her eyebrows and lining the hairs up in rows on a handkerchief, while her partner she’s sharing a bed with speaks to his girlfriend on the phone, saying how he’s “definetly not seeing anyone else”. A “battle of attrition” is the term used, and each pluncked eyebrow represents the pains of each day which she lines up with a sort of pride. The other metaphor used is waiting for her train to come, surviving the desert heat with that hope in mind. The skit with her overthinking how to lie in bed because it could show her as needy or distant is particuarly amusing, overall this is one of the series’ stronger episodes.
In this episode all the characters are animals. There doesn’t seeem to be a reason for this other than to achieve a more lighthearted tone with the humour and other than that their isn’t too much to say about this episode. It has a similar format to the first with short skits seperated by a still shot of Ekoda with a rose in her mouth, however the overall tone between them seems far more streamlined, perhaps due to the colourful art style. The director is know for more lighthearted family comedies and that certainly comes across here. The general style of these skits sees Ekoda more as a third party, commenting on the aforementioned “birds of prey”, jealousy with her sister and aquaintances’ stories of romance. It seems more like he wanted to depict Ekoda as a hard worker who gets the short end of the stick generally.
Episode 4 – Directed by Tomomi Mochizuki
Previous Works: “The Ocean Waves”, “House of Five Leaves”, “Battery”, “Pupa”, etc
This is one director with a mixed track record, personally I’m not a fan of his style and though this episode is decent I found it one of the most forgettable. This episode weaves together a few sketches to chase the idea that by being too independant she never realised she was cutting herself off from others. Here Ekoda is not a typical woman, but her uniqueness acts as self sabotage. A lot of the focus here is on her relationship with her partner “Ma-kun”, or rather how he sees her as a friend with benefits. He doesn’t want what she wants but Ekoda is too unwilling to act, just taking life as it comes and realising that it has escaped her. The themes are clear and the episode is going for a laid back feel, but with the toned down art style there isn’t really much great in this one other than the interesting take on the character which Mochizuki seems to have.
The art-style does a lot for this episode, with pencil like sketches really standing out, working well with the more whimsical nature in this short. Fast paced and weird (in a good way), Ekoda paints herself to become a hero before taking on a lizard, cockroach and mosquito. The idea seems to be that she is too carefree to live as a pet owner, with only a little bamboo plant in her home. It also flashes back to other manga skits, some of which were shown in previous episodes, but just using the punchlines so it largely works well. The way they show motion through the animation is visually pleasing, while the sound effects and music being done by human voice is a nice touch. Yonetani has shown himself to be a decent director and though this episode isn’t the most stand-out it’s weirdly fun.
This is the rotoscope animation episode. Rotoscope is the process of animating over live-action footage frame by frame, giving a strange uncanny-valley feel. I’ve always liked the process because of how unusual it is, though many would regard it as “ugly”, having notably fluid animation and often choosing a more realistic and muted colour scheme to match. Takahashi is also considered by many a classic director for producing some hit, but mainly more niche, mecha series, in particular “Votoms”. As such this is a very different approach than I’d except for one usually dealing with the fantastical and melodramatic, a down to Earth depiction of a working woman. Aiming for a nice and positive feel rather than going for humour, as Ekoda returns from work and cooks naked before recieving a call and abandoning her meal for a night out. It tries to push the metaphor that women have many sides to their personality and that at her age she still has a youthful cunning to her, a passion that she has yet to abandon. Overall enjoyable but quite forgettable.
Episode 7 – Directed by Shin Misawa
Previous Works: “Gingitsune”, “Hang in there Tsuyoshi”, “Time of Shura”, “Fire Emblem”, etc.
Misawa is a man without many works under his belt, other than “Gingitsune” many are unknown in the West and have little acclaim. This is an episode that manages to work well as an entertaining and fun idea. The concept is based around the “red string of fate”, a sort of Eastern fairy tale (with a gruesome basis) that binds lovers together. The majority occurs in Ekoda’s dreams, as she discovers the aforementioned “Ma-kun” is not bound to her, so she attempt to follow her string into a giant sky ball of string to try and tie their fates together. This leads to her failure and realisation that the only people in life she has a fate with are her mother and sister. It’s a dark take done in an amusing way. The background art and spectacle are impressive, however the character art doesn’t quite match, looking a little out of place.
Kojima largely handles adaptions closely to the source material, small changes to keep the vision of the creator the same. It’s good to see him get a little more freedom here, as he centers the episode not on Ekoda but “friend M”. It starts with “M” at a party, drinking with a table of drunk guys who are discussing rumours about Ekoda, like her real job, asking where she is. It’s based around her friends growing jealousy but when she goes to see Ekoda and sees her dateless she kind of forgets about that, caring for her instead. It’s a sort of friendly rivalry and respect that shows how others view the titular character, as someone living a carefree lifestyle with its ups and downs. I really like the letterboxing effect as if it’s being shown on a CRT and the way the artstyle juxtaposes the sharp character models on a flat less-defined background looks great. An episode that doesn’t say a lot, going by quickly, but charming nevertheless.
Episode 9 – Directed by Takeo Takahashi
Previous Works: “Citrus”, “Maoyuu Maou Yuusha”, “Spice and Wolf”, “Rokka no Yuusha”, etc
This was actually one of the most memorable episodes, with the whole short being told from a first person perspective as Ekoda works at an insurance company call centre. The way you hear her inner thought trying to pass the time, to find joy in her menial task, is really entertaining and works great in making her seem like more of a relateable character. By having more people in the shots across the office it feels less like a look into a woman’s sad private life and more like she’s being watched as part of the corporate machine. She’s unable to even stop when disaster strikes and her work colleagues go mad at a sudden change to their routine. Visually this episode looks really nice, more due to the lack of first person viewpoints used in the medium. It’s a shame that this was the only episode without a director interview because he gets anxiety being on camera apparently.
Episode 10 – Directed by Hiroshi Nagahama
Previous Works: “Aku no Hana”, “Detroit Metal City”, “Mushishi”, “The Reflection”, etc
The worst episode. NEXT!
…
Okay I guess I have to talk about it. I had hope in the first 15-seconds as a bright blue and yellow Ekoda appears on screen in front of the chair from “Mastermind” for a quick introduction. The rest of the episode is a song about Ekoda, sung by five voice actresses sounding like they’re having an emotional breakdown while stood behind a curtain with their heads inside puppets that then have the faces animated over. Nagahama directs some weird shows but this is the most bizarre thing, if you can call it his work. The idea was actually from his modern artist friend who makes mannequins and he though “it’d be so weird that people would find it hilarious”. Well it’s so weird that it’s kind of terrible, so you met one of your goals there. The song lyrics aren’t even amusing, it’s just a general summary of Ekoda’s personality.
30-seconds into this episode I thought “I bet this guy directed Beck or something”, low and behold I was right. This episode is my favourite visually, with the sketched aethestic looking gorgeous, while Kobayashi’s signiture “rock” style is apparent. Surprisingly Kobayashi hasn’t worked on many shows as chief director, thought I can believe that from the interview which is done not in the recording studio but at what looks like a bar. The interview is more of a conversation between him and his four voice actor/musician friends who he had in the episode, without them actually talking much about it, as music seems to be his main passion. This is actually a good thing, as the material of the episode works better with the director’s style, with great music and art. The episode consists of Ekoda going on a date with a rock fan, then a shoegaze fan, who seem obsessed with their musical choices rather than paying her due attention, labeling them as “worthless guys”. This is one of the standout episodes and very enjoyable to boot.
Episode 12 – Directed by Kouji Morimoto
Previous Works: “Memories”, “The Animatrix”, “Genius Party Beyond”, “Fly! Peek the Whale”, etc.
Morimoto is one of the founders of Studio 4°C, a studio well known for their shorts and video game cutscenes, and as such he works almost exclusively on shorts which is a rarity. This interview section is actually pretty great as it starts with him saying “they told me I could do whatever I wanted but then they kept turning down my ideas saying we couldn’t do that. So what if there are nipples, we all have them so I don’t see an issue with them on a late night cartoon”. Though the animation frames here are limited, it looks more stylish than cheap (unlike in episode 1) with the sharp lines and colour flair. The focus of this episode sees Ekoda sat watching TV in her apartment while pretending to be ignorant of her age to maintain her carefree attitude. It’s one of the few humour based episodes where the joke punchlines actually hit quite well. Plus what better way to end this bizarre series than by having her heart swayed by catgirl idol singers before flashing a stalker. I feel like the show is trying to display the importance of living life as you see fit and not worrying about expectations or the “norms” that society puts on women, especially in Japan.
(The second part of my Anime News Network application.)
Synopsis
Akira Tachibana was set to be
the star athlete of her high school track team, until a severe foot injury put
an end to her career. Lost and withdrawn, the high schooler finds solace in her
part-time job at the Garden Café, or more specifically in the Café’s middle
aged manager whom she develops a crush for. Masami Kondo is a single father who
spends his waning years recalling his youth and the dreams he left behind. Can
this reserved girl find a way to express her feelings for him? Beneath the
pouring rain, they find something in each other, a kindness amongst the storm,
but can they see the light that comes after the rain.
Review
Directed by Ayumu Watanabe, whose previous works include Space Brothers and Mysterious Girlfriend X, and based on the manga by Jun Mayuzukia, comes a show about a 17-year-old girl falling in love with a 45-year-old single father. My initial reaction to this show’s premise can be easily summed up with a simple word:“nope”. I thought I’d know exactly what I’d be getting into, an uncomfortable age play fantasy where any middle aged salaryman can bag himself a teenage girl. If I had stuck with that original gut reaction then I would’ve missed a gem of a show.
The premise for “After the Rain” is highly misleading, as despite itself this show is not a romance with a considerable age gap. This show is about two broken characters, people coming from different generations and different worlds, and how they inevitable effect one another’s lives. The show opens with protagonist Tachibana raising her head from her school desk, earphones falling out to find an empty classroom. This moment perfectly displays her feelings of being alone, someone who has been left behind by her cohort. The song she’s listening too in this moment is a nice play on words “Ref:rain”, as all that fills her mind is her own refrain, the idea that she’s holding herself back… that is until the song ceases as her phone flashes with “work”.
The upbeat atmosphere of the vibrant, fun opening filled with cute animals and the theme of love creates a harsh contrast to the show that follows. This opening sequence represents the desires of Tachibana, to be seen as a woman, confess and learn about love, a fantasy in comparison to the moody atmosphere created through the imagery of the rain. Though using weather as a metaphor for the protagonist’s emotional state is a fairly simple writing technique, the way it so closely links throughout the show’s entirety to a character who struggles to express herself is in no way lazy.
The title of the show reflects this feeling, Tachibana is waiting for the turmoil in her life to end. Rather than following a character who fights for romance we follow one who is looking for shelter from the rain, waiting for it to blow over, a shelter represented by the Garden. The Garden is a family restaurant run by Masami Kondo, a place she first visited after her accident where the kindness of the restaurant manager gave her a new place to belong, somewhere to run away from her problems under the guise of a part-time job.
Tonally the show itself is very mellow, it’s use of soft colours complementing a more reserved shoujo art style. “After the Rain” is at its core an aesthetically pleasing series, attractive visuals as the kind of show in which the attention of shots will linger on background details, framing used to give the world a familiar tone. In addition realistic but unique character designs give feeling to a number of the cast. The sound design compliments this exceptionally well, but is very muted, not a soundtrack that one would listen to on its own as the music is used more to set the tone rather than deliver emotional punches.
By switching viewpoints and narration between Tachibana and Kondo, the show manages to maintain a balance between typical shoujo and seinen writing styles, without falling foul to typical conventions of either. This is something that comes forth as one of the show’s greatest strengths, managing to explore two very different characters without appealing to one sole audience. “After the Rain” takes inspiration from renowned film director Akira Kurasawa, which can be seen through its pacing and framing, sharing its name with the final script Kurasawa wrote and mirroring certain themes from “Rashomon”.
Part of the show’s depth, something potentially lost on a Western audience, is the Rashomon effect. This is the concept of various characters showing different interpretations of the same incident, displayed in how the moments shared between Tachibana and Kondo have a different impact and implication upon both. The show references and at one point has the characters discuss their interpretation of the moral ambiguity of thieving to survive, highlighting their standpoints as very different characters whose approaches are not subjectively wrong.
Focus on the two protagonists is key in “After the Rain”, both to the show’s strength and detriment. Though Tachibana is very well realised as a character she’s hard to relate to as a sports prodigy who suffers an accident and longs after a middle aged man. On top of this being emotionally reclusive mean the show is often a slow exercise in ‘show don’t tell’. In comparison, depending on the individual, Kondo seems like a much more relatable character. Someone openly acknowledging a lifetime regrets and mistakes but still showing room to grow makes him an inspiring character. His problems are more applicable as someone who has forgotten his grounded dream of writing to find he’s devoted his life to work.
Outside of these characters that make up the show’s core, the rest of the cast seems more throwaway. Akira’s childhood friend Haruka is given significant time but seems more two-dimensional in comparison. Though not a bad character the subplot of their rocky friendship has more appeal from Akira’s standpoint than Haruka’s attempts to understand her emotionally recluse fallen idol. Though other characters have their memorable moments their plot points are pushed aside towards the series ending, given too little time to have a significant impact. This gives the impression that the course of the plot wasn’t entirely plotted during writing. One such plot point sees a workmate blackmailing Akira into going on a date with him, this quite sinister turn seems out of place but is pretty much forgotten afterwards, they still work together with little impact leaving me feeling like what was the point? The largest hurdle for enjoyment here is still the misleading direction, those looking for romantic impact rather than a character drama will likely end up disappointed.
“After the Rain” is a series that may struggle to connect with some, choosing to slowly and tenderly pull at your heart strings rather than provide hard hitting emotional moments, however doesn’t fail to impress with a grounded and interesting take on a taboo topic. Akira and Kondo aren’t learning to love each other, they’re remembering how to love themselves again. Despite ending with a sizzle rather than a bang, that’s fine, because the journey this show took me on isn’t one I will forget any time soon.
Grade
Overall (sub) : A-
Story : A-
Animation : B
Art : B+
Music : B
+ : A pretty and touching yet mellow tale, written
with consideration of the mental struggles all ages are faced with. Beautiful
design leaves a lasting impression.
– : Music is only fine, animation is only okay in comparison
to the art design. Misleading direction.
(I actually wrote this earlier in the year as part of an application I sent to Anime News Network. Still a little salty that I didn’t get a reply so might as well post it here.)
I was catching up with the recent anime adaption of the game “Persona 5” when a certain inclusion reminded me of something I had hoped to forget. It was 2017 and I’d finally gotten my hands on “Persona 5”, a game I’d been highly anticipating as a fan of the franchise, but the delays seemed to be worth it for the stylish, engaging product we got. Well for the most part…. There was one moment in particular that rubbed me the wrong way, the appearance of these two characters:
The recurring characters of Beefy Trendsetter and Scruffy Romantic left me with one question, why are characters like this still appearing in this day and age? “Persona 4” came out in 2008 and that had a character struggling with their sexual identity in addition to a potentially dateable male character. While the latter was pulled just before release, this felt like a step in the right direction. It felt like a punch in the gut seeing these outdated comedy stereotypes of gay sexual predators making advances on teenage boys. It’s not funny especially in contrast with the attempts of the game to approach serious topics such as sexual harassment of female students by a teacher.
That being said I don’t think the choice to include these
characters was done out of malice, in fact the game also features a character
in drag running a bar who is presented much better. It feels more like a lack
of understanding as to why this sort of representation is wrong. Every country
has had its own issues with LGBT representation, Japan being no stranger to
this. An example being comments by lower house liberal-democrat politician Mio
Sugita in July of 2018 calling same-sex couples “unproductive”, questioning
whether they were deserving of equal welfare benefits. Not the only comments of
this nature made by the ruling house member. This led me to thinking, as an
artform how does anime of the 21st century deal with a hot topic
such as LGBT representation?
BL and the Okama Effect
BL, or Boys-Love, is the first thought of most when they think of gay representation. However despite a notable manga following very few anime are released in this genre. There is also a gray area as to what defines BL, being made up of yaoi and shounen ai depending on the romantic vs sexual aspects of the character’s relationships. Exploring the ideas of “forbidden love” comes with its own problematic notions, early anime adaptions often being classed as hentai with sexual harassment rather than depicting healthy same-sex relationships, something which gives the genre a bad impression amongst anime fans.
Questionable themes are still prevalent, an example of this being 2016’s “Super Lovers”, following an 8-year-old adopted by his 16-year-old step-brother. Though this 8-year-old eventually becomes 16, the not-at-all subtle undertones of child grooming were more than enough to put BL fans off. There is a definite market here, as is obvious by the popularity of sports anime amongst the BL fandom. Despite this numerous studios are unwilling to adapt some of the more well received BL manga. One example of this is “Doukyuusei” or “Classmates”, a 2016 movie adapting the short 2006 manga of the same name by Asumiko Nakamura, depicting a sweet and simple romance between two male classmates from their initial development of feelings for one another to balancing this young love against their future aspirations.
Though representation in this field can often be respectful, this is still a niche genre unlikely to reach further than its niche audience, so how is the LGBT community represented in a more mainstream sense? Outside this specific subgenre, many references to homosexuality are in line with a character created in the 1980s, Homoo Homooda, often depicted as an over exaggeration of homosexual stereotypes with dark drawn on stubble, heavy make up and a lace fan. Not only did this character introduce the slur “h**o” to Japan but became the go to depiction for “okama” (a slang term for gay men). The extent of this stereotype’s usage in anime varies: however, being seen in popular shows such as Leeron from Gurren Lagann and Bon Clay from One Piece, who despite showing outdated characterisations are often depicted as reliable, understanding and heroic individuals.
Devilman in the Franxx: Polarising Opinions
More modern takes are starting to move away from these tropes to tackle representation itself. Two very different approaches can be seen in two of 2018’s most popular series, “Devilman Crybaby” and “Darling in the Franxx”. The 1972 “Devilman” manga saw people turning against each other over fears that any regular looking person could be a devil in disguise, only for humanity to prove themselves as the greater monsters. Though the theme of non-heterosexual love was present in part, director Masaaki Yuasa’s foray into the franchise took these themes and broadened them to compare the “Devilmen” and homosexuality in a fascinating take. Devilmen are individuals with the heart of a human and the power of a demon, similar to protagonist Akira, with the introduction of two reimagined Devilmen to this adaption for the sake of this comparison.
The first is Miko, childhood friend of track team star Miki Makimura, whose life in her shadow has spurred a jealous hatred towards her alongside feelings of worthlessness, seen as she allows men to have their way with her. This is the original impression we’re given of Miko, but over the course of the series it is revealed that this isn’t her true character, but a façade that she tries to trick herself with in an attempt to hide her true feelings of romance towards Miki. She comes to this conclusion after finding no pleasure in either sexual or romantic advances from men, followed by her transformation into a devilman and her coming to terms that it’s okay to show who she truly is as those she cares about most will accept her no matter what, even if she is shunned by society.
At the other end of the scale we are introduced to Koda, a famous up-and-coming athlete more willing to accept his sexuality and identity as a devilman. A character surrounded by rumours and whose identity resulted in the accidental death of his lover, he has no one to rely on, instead believing society’s claims that he is a monster, someone who cannot fit in and instead chooses to join the demon’s side. Yuasa manages to seamlessly introduce underlying themes of sexual identity and societal expectations into a classic work without them appearing out of place, subtle comments that one does not need to notice to enjoy the work.
In comparison the comments on homosexuality made in “Darling in the Franxx” stick out like a sore thumb. Though much of it’s fanbase turned against the show due to “lazy writing” towards it’s finale, the seeds of disappointment were sown considerably earlier. The show features teenagers piloting mecha in a two-person unit, one male one female, a sexual metaphor that is in no way attempting to be subtle as they have to synchronise and rely on each other while the male character holds the female’s “butt handles”.
Enter Mitsuru, a character initially portrayed as a rival attempting to prove himself superior to our protagonist Hiro. However it is later revealed that this hatred stems from his true feelings of love for Hiro as the first person who showed him any affection and the person who gave him his name and identity. At the time I was interested as to where this was going but did not expect the character to be told that he was not in fact in love with Hiro; he was just confused because Hiro showed him affection. Over the course of the series another character “Kokoro” develops feelings for Mitsuru, which he does not reciprocate, however the show frames it as his duty to give up on his dream of piloting a mecha with Hiro and instead he must father Kokoro’s child, growing to love her over time and acting as a reliable husband.
To emphasise these themes, they’re repeated with a fellow pilot Ikuno, who expresses her love for squad leader Ichigo and her desire to pilot with her, only for this to be shrugged away as mistaken kindness. Following this we do get a scene showing a same-sex piloting attempt, but Ichigo is uncomfortable and half-hearted making this seem unnatural. This results in Ikuno remaining paired with fellow outcast Futoshi, who isn’t physically good enough to provide for Kokoro and has a scene where he acts as the priest for her wedding, taking on a literally celibate role. While “Devilman Crybaby” highlights the need for acceptance, “Darling in the Franxx” highlights the ideology of homosexuality being unproductive for society and the greater good.
The Influence of a Director’s legacy
One of the most well-known directors when it comes to LGBT representation in anime is Kunihiko Ikuhara, who despite his small portfolio has produced cult classics as the creator of “Revolutionary Girl Utena” and director of a significant amount of “Sailor Moon”. “Sailor Moon” created a phenomenon with the inclusion of one of the first canon lesbian couples of Sailor Venus and Uranus, while Utena saw a unique spin on the shoujo genre with a lead female aspiring to the role of a dashing prince and providing a psychological exploration of sexuality. Yet after this there was a notable gap of 12 years before his next significant directorial role in the 2011 show “Mawaru Penguindrum”.
While no stranger to controversial topics this series took a back step from homosexuality, the theme appearing in only a minimal amount of episodes surrounding the character of “Yuri”, who is initially presented as a strong yet elegant shoujo style character. However, another hidden side to her is revealed, characterised by the love she held for her deceased childhood saviour Momoka, leaving an emptiness that no man can fill. Despite believing herself to be an ugly human who requires fixing, someone who’ll never be accepted according to her father and sole family member, it’s the acceptance of a caring stranger that gives her a place to belong, a love that becomes her identity not just a passing phase. The depiction of this character shows her as imperfect though, abuse by her father has in turn caused her to be uncaring and abusive to others, while less of a statement on her sexuality it does lead to one uncomfortable scene in her actions towards another female character.
Ikuhara’s next foray into animation, 2015’s “Yuri Kuma Arashi” or the literal translation “Lesbian Bear Storm”, returned to focus on societal views of homosexuality. This show was widely divisive and failed to garner the popularity of Ikuhara’s previous works due to its attempts at comparing the portrayal of lesbians in wider media with anime fandom, rather than attempting to appeal to the yuri fanbase amongst other criticisms. The plot centres on the segregation of two separate worlds with two separate ideals. The human world sees lesbianism as a secretive activity to be kept behind closed doors as the young maidens of this world must retain their purity, their romances are very of the moment. It is in this world that the invisible storm occurs, a force that punishes those society chooses to exclude or rather those who choose to act outside the norm and display their sexuality rather than allow it to remain hidden. This is a clear statement on the lack of acceptance society has for homosexuality, expecting this to be just a phase of youth, while commenting on the yuri genres idealistic views of pure love alongside unrealistic standards of femininity and solidarity.
In comparison we see the world of the bears, who despite their cute appearance are dangerous predators that must be hunted down before they taint youth’s innocence and eat them leading to their death, portraying lesbianism as a danger towards youth that must be ousted. As a vicious form of sexuality in comparison to a chase one, both are shown as broken realities. With love portrayed between our two protagonists, between a bear and a human from different worlds, a love they must constantly stand trial for, must constantly defend, it is deemed a love that does not belong in either world. In other words a healthy homosexual relationship falls foul to a lifetime of oppression. The ideas explored are not new in the world of yuri manga, with many titles exploring relationships between adult women. Hence these arguably dated ideas affected the impact this show had at the time of its release rather than it’s more pressing societal commentary.
The Struggles of Trans Recognition
Though homosexuality is still a niche theme in anime it is far more prevalent than other LGBT areas. This is one of the reasons for the notoriety of “Wandering Son”, a 2011 series based on the long running manga of the same name providing a respectful yet serious take on transsexuality and gender identity of teenagers. The show follows Shuuichi Nitori, who despite being male enjoys wearing women’s clothing and appearing effeminate, and their classmate Yoshino Takatsuki, who is uncomfortable with identifying as female, choosing to attend school in the male uniform, for example. They find comfort in one another, with Nitori displaying a longing to be a female in love with a male Yoshino.
The plot not only explores gender identity but the conflicts that come with this, discovering yourself through puberty, how this affects your relationships, acceptance from family and friends, all while displaying a childlike innocence in its approach as mirrored by the soft colour palette and art style. A prime example of this occurs in the episode where Nitori plans to attend school in a female uniform, unable to see what sort of reaction this would have, stubborn in his resolve despite the advice of his friends because if female students can wear a male uniform why can’t Nitori do the reverse. “Wandering Son” is unique in its resolve to approach a difficult topic in a genuine and often harsh way, choosing realism over sugar coating, one which pays off by promoting better understanding of trans identity.
With Ikuhara’s new show “Sarazanmai” set to release in
April it is theorised that this work will centre on homosexuality in teenage
boys, further pushing the development of sexual representation in anime. Though
negative depictions still exist in modern Japanese animation, anime exists as a
unique means to express commentary on current Japanese society and to push
boundaries in both a positive and negative light. The popularity of recent
manga such as “My Brother’s Husband” and “My lesbian experience with
loneliness”, exploring the sociological aspects of homosexuality, show that now
more than ever there is a market for LGBT representation across various media
forms. Especially in Japan following years of such topics being unwelcome
discussion in light of social conformity and a lack of LGBT rights.
Writing a blog seems like something that’d normally be against my nature but here we are. In general I actively avoid talking about myself, I like to limit people’s knowledge about me to the fact that I’m 23, am a huge nerd and that I like cats. This seems to be enough for most, just listen to them rant about their problems, offer common sense solutions like you’re the next Wiki How and you become the wise stoic friend rather than being ousted as the socially awkward mess you really are. Did I mention I liked cats because here are my cats?
Chi and Tsuki, my feline muses.
So why start a blog at all?
A mixture of writing practise and the opportunity to vent all the vast knowledge/opinions I have on useless nerd culture like the robot from Rocky IV. Plus it’s a way to seem productive. I’m the kind of guy who doesn’t like doing things, or people, so I especially don’t like doing things with people. Hence when asked if I want to go out and do stuff the answer is consistently “no I’d rather make an excuse, go home and feel guilty about saying no”.
As such this blog will be mainly me giving my opinions on anime, games, film, TV, music, the usual nerd affair, while giving the odd opinion piece on the current state of media industries and a rare insight into the life of white male millenial because god knows we don’t have enough of those on the internet. I guess you could say I’m an aspiring writer, though I can’t bring myself to attempt my book ideas because the concept seems so overwhelming, so as I fancy myself a critic what better to do than yell each week about things in an objective yet highly opinionated fashion.
Never forget.
Who is the man behind the curtain?
So my real name’s James and I was born in Manchester, England in 1995, the oldest of two children. I didn’t grow up in the worst area, but let’s just say that last week a man who thought I was posh changed his attitude completely and winced when I told him where I was from. At 13 or 14 I moved to a village in Cheshire, a county filled with large manor houses and pubs that serve £30 steaks rather than chavs and high crime rates. I attended a Catholic boys school, though I’m not religious just far left (this isn’t a politics blog though). I got along with pretty much everyone but was never particularly close to anyone, so I essentially lived the hermit lifestyle.
At the moment I’ve reached the “what am I even doing with my life” stage. Recently moved back home after four years at university pretending to be a scientist, it’s like regressing back to who you were pre-uni. Currently job searching while working part time minimum wage jobs and being the perfect househusbando. Went to uni at Keele, a place with literally nothing but the university, but it’s in the Stoke-On-Trent area. Stoke being a magical place filled with oatcakes, people calling you duck and drunks by midday. There I was king of the nerd societies, running my own con, and met my partner of three years.
This anime girl in Manchester no longer exists and it’s a crime against the 80’s.
Why am I such a nerd?
I always had a fascination with media, the idea that someone puts a piece of themselves into their work because they have a story to tell, that they leave behind a life’s work. From a film, song, etc, which someone releases you can get a real feel of that person, their principles and their style, an understanding of what they’re trying to tell you on an emotional level that you can’t achieve just conversing with people in everyday life. As such I’ve always had a big thing about whether something is an artpiece produced with heart or whether it’s just a souless cash grab.
Because I never went outside and the height of male conversation was “do you like Man City or Man U?”, I instead spent my time consuming media like my life depended on it. Initially I was a big film buff, horror movies and martial arts flicks were my thing, so much so that I did kung-fu for about 7 years. Later I got into comics, more a Marvel/X-men kinda guy, and music, alt/classic rock. Only got into anime at about 15, I’d seen plenty of stuff before but never really sought it out until I sort of realised how unique the aproach to the creation process was in the far East, a contrast to the usual Hollywood flair that Western movies seemed to succumb to. I’ve always been a Sony kid too.
Geek in the Shell 