Spoiler-Free. (Also known as “Swing and Miss Marvel”)

“Wow, this certain is a film”. That thought was on my mind during the majority of Captain Marvel’s runtime. From this you might think I found it boring, oh no sir there’s a ton of things to talk about on this one because it’s kind of a fascinating hot mess. Back when I was an early teen I went through my Marvel comics phase after getting my hands on my father’s old comic collection, meaning I fawned over 90’s X-men and especially those inital Marvel movies. At the time they felt so fresh and unique, a high budget hero spectacular to please fans that despite having short-comings (such as “Hulk” or “Daredevil”) they tried something different to get away from the edgy anti-hero flicks of the 90’s.
Flash forward to now however and I tapped out of the Marvel cinematic universe half way through “Avengers 2”. I was burnt out, the film didn’t give me any reason to care about these characters so I just stopped. It’s not that the films had gone bad, it’s down more to the phrase “you can have too much of a good thing”. In order to meet the grand visions they’d had for the Marvel universe, creating the ultimate cinematic crossover, it felt like the other films had become an afterthought prioritising the need for fanservice over uniqueness. Rather than taking risks the films started to play it safe, following the tried and true formula to produce for deadlines, building a bigger picture rather than concentrating on individual stand alone experiences.

Captain Marvel does not break this formula. With the release of DC’s “Wonder Woman” on the horizon it felt like Marvel Studios decided they couldn’t be outdone and needed their own female protagonist rather than relying on adding Scarlet Johansson into the background of films about hot, sometimes topless, manly men. They needed to give this character a big appearance in the “Avengers” so they planned their debut of Captain Marvel right between their two part epic, setting it a strict deadline. I think this was the first huge error in producing this film.
The film feels very rushed despite development supposedly starting around the same time as “Guardians of the Galaxy”, released five years prior, and despite having numerous release date delays by about 9 months. My first thoughts after leaving the cinema were that they really didn’t know what to do with this film and no director wanted to touch it with a ten foot pole, nor do I blame them. Being flaunted as the first big female protagonist for Marvel (because everyone forgets Jessica Jones and 2005’s Electra) the film was prey to right wing trolls screaming about feminism taking over, while being a property that the studio themselves had stated they hadn’t figured out what to do with. Eventually Anna Boden and Ryan Fleck, a relatively unknown duo, stepped up to direct in April 2017. To show how late this was “Avenger’s Endgame”, due to release in April 2019, finished filming on January 11th 2018 before filming on “Captain Marvel” had even started.
In truth I had actually been looking forward to this film, I’d always had a soft spot for the heroines of Marvel. Despite being far and few between, characters like She-Hulk, Spider Woman and more recently Spider Gwen, were all strong, confident and most importantly bad-ass women. You could tell a lot of effort went into giving them plotlines with more of a unique flavour. Ms. Marvel seemed like a great choice for an adaption (teen me crushed hard on Carol Danvers), I’d always liked the weird alien side of the Marvel Universe and this had the potential to offer a quirky, weird and wonderful take in the same style that made “Guardians of the Galaxy” stand out. Plus I’m a millenial so the 90’s references and presence of a cat meant I kinda had to see it.
The easiest sign that this film was rushed is the CG effects, when compared to other Marvel movies they’re at best passable, none of the set pieces really blow you away. At worst it had me muttering “wow that looks terrible”. There were some scenes featuring the cat where I just don’t know how someone could’ve seen it and thought “yeah, that looks fine. Perfectly like a real cat”. While the initial set pieces showing an alien civilisation are impressive it isn’t long before bland movie set corridors are brought out instead. That would’ve been okay if the writing made up for it but it did not.

I’d heard talk about how “the film was super-feminist” and “anti-white male”, so I was surprised at how inoffensive it was. You could tell they played it safe as to not offend anti-feminist trolls and this was the films second big mistake. If you’re pushing the fact that this film has a female lead then embrace that within the film, instead Captain Marvel has a role that could’ve been played by a man and it wouldn’t have changed anything. Having to overcome the hardships placed on women in society, in any way, would have made her a considerably more interesting character. Rather than “women can be just as good as men”, showing how a super-powered heroine can be different in her own bad-ass way is a far more rewarding plotline.
Despite this the film still has “girl-power” moments which don’t tonally fit because she never has to deal with being put down because of her sex. She blows up a screen showing a guy who said “she’s emotional and can’t fly a plane because it’s called a cockpit”, but this isn’t an important factor to her character. She’s a skilled pilot and soldier so it has no meaning. The stand out moment for this was an action scene late in the movie where “Just a Girl” by “No doubt” plays; there is no point where Captain Marvel is just a girl. Throughout the whole film she is an super soldier who then discovers how to go super saiyan, so a song about breaking gender stereotypes just doesn’t fit. At no point is she a relatable character showing vulnerability, if anything Samuel L. Jackson makes a more relatable protagonist.

“Guardian’s of the Galaxy” was defined by it’s soundtrack, a classic homage which fit perfectly. “Captain Marvel” attempted to recreate this with 90’s nostalgia. I love the soundtrack because I’m all about alt 90’s rock, but it feels more like the director is playing their mixtape rather than choosing songs that actually compliment the scenes. “Only Happy When it Rains” plays, but it isn’t raining and she isn’t sad, she’s just riding through the desert. (“Favourite Game” would’ve been a better choice just saying). At one point “Come as you are” by “Nirvana” suddenly plays and I wasn’t the only one in the cinema with a look of confusion. The other 90’s nostagia pulls I quite liked, but they were pretty tame and a bit too obvious.
Speaking of tonal dissonace it feels like none of the actors know how to play their roles. It feels like they didn’t know what tone to go for so everyone is slightly upbeat and quick witted at all times, even for scenes that are more emotional. It’s rare for a character to feel like an actual person. I don’t think Brie Larson was a good choice for the role, not that her acting is bad, she just doesn’t bring anything to the role. She fits the generic empowerment message well but by the end Captain Marvel herself feels like a nothing character. This doesn’t help with frequent bad dialogue and directing choices. There was one scene where I thought she was going to run away shouting “everything is lies” like Cammy in the Street Fighter cartoon.
One scene in particular stands out, as our protagonist’s long lost BFF tries to have an emotional heart to heart and Brie Larson has to play it off as a wacky loveable character, I can’t think of a single moment where something is treated seriously. It’s more like a pilot for a straight to TV teen drama. There’s even a dramatic “someone gets shot but they’re actually fine” scene. Thought I can’t go into it without spoilers, the villians are bad and have no substance to their personality or motivations. There’s even a rival female so that they can have a sassy cat fight because that is a trope people think we still need apparently. I think I’ll stick to the 90’s X-men cartoon for the best character depiction thanks.
Despite how much I’ve been ripping into this film I don’t think it’s actually bad, however I’m not sure why. It’s like what if they made “Guardians of the Galaxy” with no vision and less budget? At least they tried though. The buddy-cop road trip with Samuel L. Jackson is the most memorable part of the flick, while the use of special effects to make him look younger are excellent. Long gone are the days of shiny uncanny valley Patrick Stewart in “X-men Origins: Wolverine”. The cat is good but it was always going to be, the action choreography is decent and the Kree headgear is a nice nod to the source material. Stan Lee’s final cameo makes for a great moment too. Overall it achieves what it set out to do and if you care at all about the Marvel franchise it’s worth seeing, you may end up really enjoying the fun yet risk-free ride it takes you on, just don’t get your hopes up. It’s a fine inbetween origin story but could have been so much more. Now what we really need is a “She-Hulk” courtroom drama comedy in the style of “Scott Pilgrim vs. The World”… please?


















